The Trader’s Cycle of Improvement
Adapted from James Clear’s framework in Atomic Habits
The markets are unforgiving — they expose every flaw, amplify every weakness, and demand constant adaptation and growth. In this environment, improvement isn’t optional. Successful traders are those who are capable of extended periods of growth, both emotionally and psychologically.
If the majority of traders spent as much time on their personal development as they did on choosing the right colour for their moving averages, they would probably be much more successful.
1. Awareness – Identify what needs to change
In trading, the first battle is internal. You must see yourself — your emotional triggers, recurring mistakes, cognitive biases, and performance inconsistencies. Are you cutting winners short? Chasing trades out of boredom? Hesitating at key moments? These aren’t just strategy flaws — they are behavioural tells.
Awareness means facing your trading journal without ego. It means asking not “What went wrong?” but “What do I keep doing that I pretend I don’t?”
Most traders don’t fail because they lack knowledge — they fail because they repeat errors they’ve never stopped to truly notice.
2. Deliberate Practice – Isolate the problem, train the response
Improvement doesn’t come from taking more trades. It comes from intentionally refining your decision-making process. Deliberate practice for a trader might include:
-
Replaying missed signals using historical charts
-
Using a post-trade checklist to evaluate discipline, not just outcome
-
Defining your ability gap – how much are you leaving on the table courtesy of poor habits?
This step is hard because it’s not about performance—it’s about process. It’s uncomfortable, slow, and often humbling. But this is where the edge is forged, not in knowing more, but in executing better.
The market rewards consistency.
3. Habit – Turn process into instinct
As refinement continues, what once took effort becomes automatic. You no longer need to remind yourself to follow your stop loss. You no longer force discipline — it’s built into your routine.
Habits in trading create psychological bandwidth. They free you from constant internal debate and emotional noise. Systems become second nature. Decisions become cleaner. This is what separates amateur reaction from professional response.
In trading, you don’t rise to the level of your goals. You fall to the level of your habits.
4. Repeat – Cycle back with humility
Once something becomes a habit, the loop restarts. You return to awareness, but now at a higher resolution. The weaknesses are subtler, the refinements more nuanced and distinctly more internal.
This recursive nature of improvement keeps you humble. It forces you to continually confront the truth: in trading, there is no finish line—only refinement. However, this only applies to those who survive.
You never actually master the markets but you do begin to master yourself.
In Closing: The Trader’s Edge is Process
Edge is not just a setup or a signal; it’s a comprehensive solution. It’s a mindset—a system of personal evolution.
The best traders aren’t those who get everything right — they’re the ones who evolve faster. Markets are very Darwinian – traders who adapt quickly survive longer. The longer they survive, the more money they make, and the more money they make, the longer they survive.
Adaptation has a payoff.
Thanks for all these articles on the psychology aspect of trading Chris. Makes me laugh a little when I think back to 25 years ago when I first started trading and had a perfectly good system but no idea on money management and crucially, no idea on the psychology of trading. Hence, I sabotaged the system and abandoned it. It was the Mark Douglas book (which you may have recommended) that got me started on the psychology component. I have since returned to the original system!