Skip to content
Trading Game
Trading Game
Trade Confidently and Safely
  • Home
  • About
    • About Louise Bedford
    • About Chris Tate
    • Chris Tate Media Kit
    • Louise Bedford Media Kit
  • Why Choose Us
    • Audited Results
    • In The Press
  • Mentor Program
  • Rave Reviews
    • More Rave Reviews
    • Even More Rave Reviews
    • Extra Rave Reviews
    • Still More Rave Reviews
    • This Is Getting Ridiculous
    • Success Stories
    • More Success Stories
    • We Are Traders
    • A Poem To Inspire You…
    • Hot Off The Press Reviews
    • You Want Proof?
  • Our Network
    • Our Brokers
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • LOGIN
  • Home
  • About
    • About Louise Bedford
    • About Chris Tate
    • Chris Tate Media Kit
    • Louise Bedford Media Kit
  • Why Choose Us
    • Audited Results
    • In The Press
  • Mentor Program
  • Rave Reviews
    • More Rave Reviews
    • Even More Rave Reviews
    • Extra Rave Reviews
    • Still More Rave Reviews
    • This Is Getting Ridiculous
    • Success Stories
    • More Success Stories
    • We Are Traders
    • A Poem To Inspire You…
    • Hot Off The Press Reviews
    • You Want Proof?
  • Our Network
    • Our Brokers
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • LOGIN

More ETF Magic

You are here:
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Brokers/Fund Managers
  4. More ETF Magic

About the only joyous thing about Christmas is that there is a marked slowdown in the amount of junk  mail that hits my inbox. And to be honest I do miss the emails telling me that people have the ideal job for or that Svetlana from Kokshetau in Kazakhstan is desperate to send me pictures of her recently shorn yak. Paradoxically I have not seen a slowdown in the number of emails extolling the virtues; nay magic of index ETF’s. This got me thinking about the nature of indices and their construction. In simplest terms an index is simply an aggregation of stocks design to represent a sector of the market. However, stocks are not simply lumped into a group and passed off as an index, an index can be either price weighted such as the Dow or market value weighted index such as the S&P500.  With the Dow the weighting of each component is a function of its price whereas with the S&P500 components are weighted according to total value of their outstanding shares. Each method of construction results in a different end product.

Because we have two mechanisms of solving the same problem we can compare and contrast what each solution looks like when plotted against one another. This might seem to be a somewhat academic problem and in many ways it is is except when you consider that when being told to buy an international ETF investors are directed towards SPY which is a representation of the S&P500 –  a market weighted index. You might think so what but remember this is not the only way to measure an index and that the folks who create ETFs are nothing if not inventive. As such there is a price weighted version of the S&P500  known as the Guggenheim S&P 500® Equal Weight ETF or RSP

It is therefore easy to compare the performance of these two instruments –

etf

For the period being considered it appears as if the equal weighted version has given the market weighted ETF a bit of a belting. This raises the question as to why do dislocations occur between the performance of two indices constructed using different methodologies and the blindingly obvious answer is that it is the different methodologies account for the different performance. Granted they hold the same stocks but they hold them in different ratios. For example SPY’s largest holding is Apple which makes up 3.12% of its portfolio whereas its holding in RSP is capped at 0.21%. This means that when Apple does well SPY will do well but when it does poorly it will drag the performance down. Equal weighted indices are to some extent insulated against the travails of a single stock.

The existence of instruments such as RSP introduce a layer of complexity for ETF traders since they offer a variation on the theme of index investing that may or may not suit them. Unfortunately, for those who pump magic index ETF systems the world is a little more nuanced than they think it is.

 

Categories: Brokers/Fund Managers, International MarketsBy Chris TateDecember 29, 20162 Comments

Post navigation

PreviousPrevious post:The Pot-Belly of IgnoranceNextNext post:Conquer Your Fear

Related Posts

How To Spot Luck
May 11, 2022
Averaging Down Is Friggen Stupid
April 28, 2022
Early Candidate For Ugliest Chart of 2022
April 21, 2022
Daniel Drew: Wall Street Villain
February 23, 2022

2 Comments

  1. Nick says:
    December 29, 2016 at 2:56 pm

    I hope you are not referring to Gary Stone, Chris. His system has been backtested over several years and ETFs selected for liquidity filters too. I am happy to use his system. He offers SPY and RSP (I trade RSP as it outperforms SPY over the long term but has higher fees).

    • Tyrone says:
      December 30, 2016 at 12:52 pm

      I doubt Gary is spamming Chris’s inbox with ETF emails, so he probably isn’t referring to Gary with this article. Gary has also been a guest of Talking Trading courtesy of Chris and Louise, worth a listen to.

Comments are closed.

Trading Game
BACK TO TOP



General Advice Warning

The Trading Game Pty Ltd (ACN: 099 576 253) is an AFSL holder (Licence no: 468163). This information is correct at the time of publishing and may not be reproduced without formal permission. It is of a general nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on any of the information you should consider its appropriateness, having regard to your own objectives, financial situation and needs.

Privacy and Licensing | Terms & Conditions | Referrals

  • Home
  • About
  • Why Choose Us
  • Mentor Program
  • Rave Reviews
  • Our Network
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Contact Us
  • Log In

Copyright © The Trading Game. All Rights Reserved. | website designed by Papdan.com

Social Media: